Sunday, October 9, 2011

From the Front Lines of Happiness Research

Some scientists are kind of weird. How about these guys, who enjoy hobbling sheep?
Consider “Release from Restraint Generates a Positive Judgment Bias in Sheep” (Applied Animal Behavior Science, 2010). In this study, 20 young merino ewes were trained to distinguish between two buckets, one of which led to food and another to the appearance of a dog — a highly unpleasant sight for a young ewe. Half of the animals were then bound at their legs and isolated from the other animals for six hours, three days in a row. On release from their imprisonment, this experimental group was shown a new, “ambiguous” bucket, which did not clearly lead to either food or dog. The previously imprisoned animals, despite their elevated stress levels, were much more likely to approach the ambiguous bucket than were a control group of ewes. Against all odds, they were, in a word, optimistic that the bucket might lead to something good.
I love this result. It supports the ancient wisdom that a life free from suffering would lead nowhere good -- to increased fearfulness, perhaps -- and that bad experiences are necessary, if nothing else to teach us that failure is not the end of the world. Once you've been hobbled in solitary confinement for a while, the prospect of seeing a dog seems a lot less daunting.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

Either that, or suffering just makes you desperate.

John said...

"Be desperate. Ten men cannot stand against a desperate man."

--Hagakure

Anonymous said...

Sigh. You know, I don't think I've ever heard one of those ten-to-one slogans that had much validity. (Remember, "one free man defending his land can beat ten knights. The crusades taught me that"?)

John said...

Not in a battle, but one man willing to fight to the death can sometimes intimidate a room full of of the undermotivated.

Anonymous said...

Fair enough. My real point is that, among humans, what matters isn't suffering but individual character and how that shapes one's reaction to it. Some suffer and wallow, and others suffer and overcome. And among the latter, some become great-souled, understanding the problems of those who suffer, and others simply despise the mass who have not overcome the difficulties they did, and so become terrible bosses, military officers, ship captains, etc.--or develop dangerous messianic complexes and decide that they have a "destiny."